home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=94TT0106>
- <title>
- Jan. 31, 1994: The Ice Age Cometh?
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1994
- Jan. 31, 1994 California:State of Shock
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- SCIENCE, Page 79
- The Ice Age Cometh?
- </hdr>
- <body>
- <p>Last week's big chill was a reminder that the earth's climate
- can change at any time
- </p>
- <p>By Michael D. Lemonick--Reported by David Bjerklie/New York
- </p>
- <p> Just as last week's tremors were destroying highways, buildings
- and lives in Southern California, an even deadlier natural disaster
- was advancing slowly but inexorably south from Canada into the
- U.S. By midweek a huge mass of frigid arctic air had practically
- paralyzed much of the Midwest and East. Temperatures in dozens
- of cities dropped to all-time lows: -22 degreesF in Pittsburgh;
- -25 degrees in Akron, Ohio, and Clarksburg, West Virginia; -27
- degrees in Indianapolis, Indiana. Chicago schools closed because
- of cold weather for the first time in history, Federal Government
- offices shut down in Washington, and East Coast cities narrowly
- escaped widespread power outages as overburdened electric utilities
- struggled to keep homes heated. Hundreds of motorists in New
- Jersey had to be rescued by snowmobile from an impassably icy
- highway, and thousands of the homeless crammed into New York
- City's shelters to avoid freezing. By week's end the unprecedented
- cold wave had killed more than 130 people.
- </p>
- <p> What ever happened to global warming? Scientists have issued
- apocalyptic warnings for years, claiming that gases from cars,
- power plants and factories are creating a greenhouse effect
- that will boost the temperature dangerously over the next 75
- years or so. But if last week is any indication of winters to
- come, it might be more to the point to start worrying about
- the next Ice Age instead. After all, human-induced warming is
- still largely theoretical, while ice ages are an established
- part of the planet's history. The last one ended about 10,000
- years ago; the next one--for there will be a next one--could
- start tens of thousands of years from now. Or tens of years.
- Or it may have already started.
- </p>
- <p> There is no way of knowing yet: an entire winter of record-shattering
- cold, let alone a single week, might be a meaningless blip in
- the overall scheme of long-term climate trends. In fact, last
- week's cold wave was caused by a phenomenon that is by no means
- rare. The jet stream, a stratospheric wind that governs the
- movement of air over North America, dipped temporarily south
- of its usual course. As it did so, the stream pulled along a
- vast high-pressure system from Siberia and the Arctic Ocean.
- </p>
- <p> If that starts happening more and more often, though, it might
- mean that something bigger is going on. Climatologists once
- thought the world eased into ice ages, with average temperatures
- in parts of the Northern Hemisphere falling 15 degrees over
- hundreds or thousands of years. During long, frigid winters
- and short, cool summers, snow piled up much faster than it could
- melt, and mile-thick sheets of ice gradually covered much of
- the planet's land surface. After 100,000 years or so, scientists
- believed, the glaciers made a dignified retreat, stayed put
- for about 10,000 years and then began to grow again.
- </p>
- <p> But over the past several years, researchers have dug deep into
- Atlantic sea-floor sediments and Greenland glaciers to study
- the chemistry of ancient mud and ice, and they are increasingly
- convinced that climate change is anything but smooth. The transition
- from warm to frigid can come in a decade or two--a geological
- snap of the fingers. Says Gerard Bond, a geophysicist at Columbia
- University's Lamont-Doherty Observatory: "The data have been
- coming out of Greenland for maybe two or three decades. But
- the first results were really so surprising that people weren't
- ready to believe them."
- </p>
- <p> There is a growing understanding as well that ice ages are not
- uniformly icy, nor interglacial periods unchangingly warm. About
- 40,000 years ago, for example, right in the middle of the last
- Ice Age, the world warmed briefly, forcing glaciers to retreat.
- And while the current interglacial period has been stably temperate,
- the previous one, according to at least one study, was evidently
- interrupted by frigid spells lasting hundreds of years. If that
- period was more typical than the present one, humanity's invention
- of agriculture, and thus civilization, may have been possible
- only because of a highly unusual period of stable temperature--a fluke.
- </p>
- <p> Just 150 years ago, the notion that much of the Northern Hemisphere
- had once been covered by thick sheets of ice was both new and
- highly controversial. Within a few decades, though, most scientists
- were convinced and began looking for explanations. Several suggested
- that astronomical cycles were involved, and by the 1930s the
- Yugoslav astronomer Milutin Milankovitch had constructed a coherent
- theory. The ice ages, he argued, were triggered by changes in
- the shape of the earth's slightly oval orbit around the sun
- and in the planet's axis of rotation. Studies of the chemical
- composition of ocean-floor sediments, which depend on climate
- conditions when the material was laid down, more or less supported
- Milankovitch's predicted schedule of global glaciation.
- </p>
- <p> According to Milankovitch cycles, an ice age could start sometime
- within the next 1,000 or 2,000 years. But geophysicists have
- realized for years that while the cycles are real, and influence
- climate, they alone cannot explain ice ages. For one thing,
- Milankovitch's timing of glaciation may be broadly correct,
- but major glacial episodes happen when his cycles call for minor
- ones, and vice versa.
- </p>
- <p> Besides, a simple astronomical model would predict smooth and
- gradual climate transitions--the opposite of what really happens.
- The last Ice Age was in full retreat about 13,000 years ago
- when temperatures suddenly reversed and began heading lower
- again. They stayed low for 1,000 years, an episode known as
- the Younger Dryas period. The periodic "spikes" of warmer weather
- that have interrupted ice ages and the cold weather that often
- came on suddenly in the last interglacial period are also impossible
- to explain with astronomy. And so is the astonishingly rapid
- changeover from warm to cold.
- </p>
- <p> A number of theories have been floated to explain these irregular,
- rapid variations. The leading one, advanced by Lamont-Doherty's
- Wallace Broecker and George Denton of the University of Maine,
- involves a kind of cyclic ocean current that has been likened
- to a conveyer belt. Broecker and Denton note that a stream of
- unusually salty (and thus especially dense) water flows underneath
- the Gulf Stream as it moves from the tropics to the North Atlantic.
- When this salty stream reaches the far north, it is forced to
- the surface as water above it is blown aside by the winds; it
- then discharges its tropical heat into the arctic air, cools
- off and sinks to the bottom, where it returns to the tropics
- to be heated again.
- </p>
- <p> It is this current, argue Broecker and Denton, that keeps the
- Arctic relatively warm and glacier free. When it stops running,
- an ice age--or a cold spike--begins. What causes a turnoff?
- An influx of fresh water might do it, by diluting the saltiness
- and density of the current, preventing it from sinking and heading
- back to the tropics. There is evidence that at just the time
- the Younger Dryas began, a huge North American lake (which no
- longer exists) began dumping Amazonian quantities of fresh water
- into the North Atlantic. The discharge stopped about 1,000 years
- later, as did the Younger Dryas. Broecker and Denton's model,
- says Penn State's Richard Alley, an expert on Greenland ice
- cores, "is probably the trigger for these abrupt changes."
- </p>
- <p> Nobody knows what other factors might help trigger climate shifts,
- and how sensitive they are. "It scares us," says Alley. "We
- know that there are times when climate is very delicately poised.
- We know that for the past 8,000 or 10,000 years, it hasn't flipped
- over. But we don't really understand it well enough to say whether
- it's really stable or whether we are on thin ice."
- </p>
- <p> In short, while there is no reason to think the next full-fledged
- Ice Age is upon us, a shorter episode of frigid conditions could
- happen at any time. The last interglacial period was warmer
- than this one and also, arguably, more unstable. It is conceivable
- that the greenhouse effect could heat up the planet for a while
- but then trigger changes that could plunge the earth into a
- sudden chill. And for an idea of what a mini-Ice Age might be
- like, just imagine last week's cold wave lasting all winter,
- every winter--for the next thousand years.
- </p>
-
- </body>
- </article>
- </text>
-
-